Browse · MathNet
Print67th Romanian Mathematical Olympiad
Romania number theory
Problem
a) Prove that cannot be written as a sum of squares of three rational numbers.
b) Let be a rational number that can be written as a sum of squares of three rational numbers. Prove that can be written as a sum of squares of three rational numbers, for any positive integer .
b) Let be a rational number that can be written as a sum of squares of three rational numbers. Prove that can be written as a sum of squares of three rational numbers, for any positive integer .
Solution
a) Suppose, by way of contradiction, that one can find rational numbers , , such that . Writing , , as fractions and clearing denominators yield an equality like where , , , are nonnegative integers, not all zero. If is even, then , , are all even, as well (obviously, they cannot be all odd, and if exactly two of them are odd, the sum of their squares equals , while equals ). Dividing by yields and, clearly, . If is still even, we repeat the previous transformation (this can only happen finitely many times). If is odd, say , then . Since the remainder of a square when divided by equals , or , we deduce that equality is impossible.
b) We induct on . The base case follows from the hypothesis. We assume the statement true for all and prove it for . If , then , hence can be written as a sum of squares of three rational numbers, for instance , where . Then and the numbers , , are obviously rational numbers.
If , using , we get
b) We induct on . The base case follows from the hypothesis. We assume the statement true for all and prove it for . If , then , hence can be written as a sum of squares of three rational numbers, for instance , where . Then and the numbers , , are obviously rational numbers.
If , using , we get
Techniques
Techniques: modulo, size analysis, order analysis, inequalitiesPolynomial operationsInduction / smoothing